James Franco

Amy Smart

Topher Grace

Alicia Witt

Marianna Palka

Emily Grierson

Beth Grant

Zackary Arthur

Sky Azure Van Vliet

Elly

Xosha Roquemore

Young Tabitha

Janet Wood

Angie

Michael Chieffo

Mr. Grierson

Molly Berg

Rebecca

Caroline Hebert

Constance

Leslie L. Miller

Nancy

Ace Gibson

Jesus

Elayn J. Taylor

Tabitha

Terra Wellington

Elly's Aunt

Casey Kramer

Agatha

David Lee Hess

Soldier

John Knox

Elly's Father

Laura Parker

McLendon's Wife

Dennis Renard

Will Mayes